Why Did Eren Start the Rumbling? Unveiling His True Motives

Among the most startling and divisive events in contemporary Shonen manga is Eren’s choice to begin the Rumbling. It was a terrible act of genocide that left viewers wondering about his ethics and motivations, not only a story turn-around. What can inspire someone to unleash such unearthly devastation? For Eren, it was a last-ditch effort to get Paradis Island free, even if it meant playing the villain for the world.

The Rumbling represented millennia of suffering, rage, and the hard realities of survival, not only a weapon. Eren’s hard life and continuous exposure to death molded his perspective, hence serenity seems like a far-off fantasy. To him, the Rumbling was the sole means of recovering power in a society built on tyranny. Was it, however, really worth the price? Knowing Eren’s decisions requires entering the intricate network of guilt, freedom, and hard reality of his life.

The Main Reason Eren Started the Rumbling

Eren started the Rumbling to guard Paradis Island against attack. The Eldians were caught in a never-ending circle of discrimination and strife centuries of persecution and hereditary shame put. Eren thought the island’s people would suffer extinction for crimes they did not commit without extreme action.

Seeing his mother die following Wall Maria’s fall solidified Eren’s determination. For Paradis, independence seemed to be the only result worth seeking—even if it meant incroyable devastation. The force of the Attack Titan shaped his perspective and drove him toward what he considered to be a natural course.

The Rumbling was, to Eren, the perfect deterrent. He sought to guarantee the survival of his people by threatening to destroy the outer world. Though horrific in scope, his acts revealed a deliberate reaction to the cyclical violence and existential threats encircling the Eldians.

Eren’s Attack on Liberio

Eren attacked Liberio in order to decisively hit Marley and intensify the current fighting. Key military center Liberio stood in for Marley’s control and mistreatment of the Eldians. Eren upset their power system by invading Liberio and launching a surprise attack, so highlighting the extent he would be ready to go for Eldian survival.

This strike also acted as payback for Marley’s mistreatment of the Eldians. After escaping captivity on Paradis Island, Eren sought retribution for the crimes Marley had committed, including invasion of Shiganshina District. The destruction in Liberio proved his readiness to give diplomacy second priority in favor of forceful strategies.

The attack was a turning point in the series since Paradis’s offensive actions replaced his defensive ones. Eren increased his efforts to defend Paradis by focusing on outside dangers, therefore foreshadowing the Rumbling. The attack confirmed his part as a spark in the developing conflict.

The Euthanization Plan’s Role in the Rumbling

Using the Founding Titan’s capacity to stop reproduction, Zeke Yeager’s euthanasia scheme sought to eradicate the Eldian race. Zeke maintained this would break the Titans’ curse’s ongoing cycle of pain. Zeke, Eren’s half-brother, thought his answer was moral, saving next generations from inherited suffering.

Eren turned down Zeke’s vision since he saw it incompatible with his will to uphold Eldian freedom. Eliminating his people went against Eren’s intended outcome of eradicating injustice. Their different ideas collided; Eren valued agency above forced extinction. This difference motivated Eren to go after the Rumbling.

The moral consequences of the strategy increased Eren’s skepticism of inherited answers. Zeke’s strategy saw Eldians as a problem to eradicate rather than as individuals to defend. Eren opposed Zeke’s suggestion to protect Paradis Island’s future since he considered the Rumbling as the only way he could survive.

Why Did Eren Want to Start the Rumbling?

Eren aimed to launch the Rumbling to ensure Paradis Island’s people, the Eldians, would survive. He thought that their continuous persecution and threats of annihilation from the outside world left only a forceful, permanent action as alternative. Eren sought to eradicate outside elements able to endanger Paradis by releasing the enormous Titans.

His choice was driven much more by his thirst for vengeance and his disgust of centuries of Eldian suffering. Seeing his mother die and Wall Maria crumble confirmed the terrible truth of persecution, therefore strengthening his will to defend his country at any means.

Eren chose the Rumbling as a survival tool instead of extinction after rejecting Zeke Yeager’s euthanasia proposal, which called for destroying the Eldian bloodline. Eren saw the Rumbling as the only way to ensure independence for his people, even if it meant destroying the planet outside Paradis, therefore choosing force before compromise.

Ymir’s Role in The Rumbling

The Rumbling’s execution relied critically on Ymir Fritz’s relationship to the Founding Titan. She lived in the Paths dimension, the source of all Titan strength, hence forming Titans at the behest of the Founding Titan’s bearer. Bound by her residual allegiance and trauma from King Fritz’s mistreatment, her servitude to the royal line stretched 2,000 years.

Eren’s special connection with Ymir ended her pattern of compliance. Understanding her as a victim rather than a tool, he appealed to her feelings instead of using authority. Eren took over the Colasant Titans inside the Walls by convincing Ymir to allow him full authority of the Founding Titan.

Ymir made a significant change when she sided with Eren. It symbolized her release from Fritz’s grip and allowed the widespread devastation defining the Rumbling. Her contribution was crucial since Eren’s intentions could not have come true without her cooperation.

Why Was Eren Crying While Talking to Ramzi?

Eren sobbed and apologized to Ramzi for the guilt and sadness attached to his deeds. Eren witnessed the destruction the Rumbling would cause—including Ramzi’s death—using the powers of the Founding Titan. Having saved Ramzi once just to subsequently destroy him, this insight tormented him much.

The lad represented the innocent lives lost, therefore accentuating Eren’s inner struggle. The consequence of his decisions still profoundly hurt him even though he hated the repressive powers outside Paradis. His collapse exposed his humanity since he carried the shame of turning into a villain defending his own country.

Seeing continuous persecution and that the world would not pardon Eldians, Eren saw the Rumbling as unavoidable. He was so burdened by the circumstances that he begged someone who stood in for the life he could not spare for pardon in tears.

Final Thoughts on the Rumbling

One of the worst and most disastrous decisions Eren Yeager makes in Attack on Titan is releasing the Rumbling. Driven by his need for freedom and retribution, Eren saw the survival of Paradis Island dependent on the eradication of outside hazards. This deed was more than just a calculated move; it was the result of decades of persecution, inherited trauma, and personal agony over the Eldians.

Eren clearly intended to defend his people, but it is impossible to overlook the moral price of his activities. The devastation of whole countries and the death toll of many innocent people highlight the dubious character of his strategies. Eren strengthened his conviction in agency by turning down substitutes like Zeke’s euthanasia proposal, even at the price of his humanity. His partnership with Ymir Fritz exposed even more his capacity to seize opportunities by using common suffering. The Rumbling is evidence of Eren’s multifarious nature and helps to create a legacy molded by sacrifice and destruction.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did Eren start the Rumbling?

Eren started the Rumbling to guard Paradis Island and its people against extinction. Driven by millennia of suffering and personal pain, he thought the only way to eradicate outside dangers and guarantee freedom for Eldians was the massive act of destruction.

What was Eren’s biggest motivation?

Eren’s main drive was to crush the forces endangering Paradis Island’s survival, therefore guaranteeing its existence. Driven by his love to defend his people and his disgust at injustice, his choice defied the terrible moral implications.

How did Ymir Fritz play a role in the Rumbling?

mir Fritz gave Eren complete power from the Founding Titan, therefore enabling the Rumbling. Eren appealed to her emotions, releasing her from servitude to King Fritz, therefore enabling him to command the Colasant Titans.

Why did Eren reject Zeke’s euthanization plan?

Eren rejected Zeke’s euthanization plan because he valued freedom and agency. He saw Zeke’s forced extinction of the Eldian race as incompatible with his vision of preserving his people’s future and finding true freedom.

Why did Eren attack Liberio?

Eren loved agency and independence, hence he turned down Zeke’s euthanizing scheme. He considered Zeke’s forced elimination of the Eldian race as irreconcilable with his objective of saving his people’s future and discovering actual freedom.

What does Eren’s breakdown during the Rumbling signify?

Eren’s emotional collapse—best shown by his apologies to Ramzi—highlights his shame and grief at the terrible cost of his choices. It captures his great humanism and load of giving up innocent life for the survival of his people.

Is Eren a villain or a hero?

Eren’s behavior fuzzes the distinction between hero and evil. Although his intention to save Paradis is obvious, the Rumbling causes mass destruction that defines him as a problematic person marked by moral complexity and sacrifice.

Why did Eren value freedom above all else?

Eren’s upbringing amid continual dread and tyranny drove his yearning for independence. Losing his mother and seeing the misery of the Eldians confirmed his conviction that liberation was worth any sacrifice—including ethically dubious behavior.

How did the Attack Titan influence Eren’s choices?

the Attack Titan’s ability to view past and future occurrences let Eren expose unavoidable cycles of violence. This insight helped him to see that the Rumbling was the only way to guarantee freedom and stop the cycle of bloodshed.

What are the moral implications of Eren’s actions?

Eren’s decisions force readers to examine the ethics of giving millions of lives to save a small number. His behavior begs issues of agency, oppression, and whether goals may justify means, therefore casting a morally dubious picture of his character and choices.